‘Criminal Minds: Evolution’ Stars Tease Matthew Gray Gubler’s Return for ‘Life-Changing Experience’

A.J. Cook as Jennifer ‘JJ’ Jareau, Aisha Tyler as Dr. Tara Lewis, Adam Rodriguez as Luke Alvez, RJ Hatanaka as Tyler Green, Paget Brewster as Emily Prentiss, Kirsten Vangsness as Penelope Garcia, and Joe Mantegna as David Rossi in Criminal Minds: Evolution, season 18

At some point this season, Criminal Minds: Evolution is briefly getting the gang all back together with the return of Matthew Gray Gubler. Dr. Spencer Reid was still with the BAU when the original Criminal Minds run ended in 2020, but Gubler didn’t return for the revival, with the explanation given that his character’s off on a special assignment. (Such is the case for Daniel Henney‘s Matt Simmons as well.) When TV Insider spoke with cast members recently about the new season, we tried to get teases about his return.

Aisha Tyler (Lewis) and Adam Rodriguez (Alvez) were very cagey when they stopped by our offices (watch the video interview above for a deep dive into Season 18 Episode 2).

“You’ll see him, and I’ll say this, it’s nice to see him. I think everybody will appreciate seeing him and we all enjoyed the time that he was there with us,” shared Rodriguez. “It was good to see him in real life, and it’ll be, I think, nice for the fans to see him pop up as well.” Tyler likened it to “a family reunion.”

Kirsten Vangsness (Garcia) offered a bit more of a preview.

“I think one of the reasons why people love Criminal Minds is that — you come for the gory, scary, spooky horror aspect, sure people come for that, but people also come for the family dynamic and the ride or dies and that community that we’ve built, that we’ve created as people and then these characters have created themselves,” she suggested. “So whenever things happen that tear the environment asunder, for better or for worse, it’s Avengers Assemble in the biggest way we can. So this was definitely a — you need him there to, of course, of course, he would be there for these big, pivotal life-changing experiences. And so it really felt very satisfying and I think it’ll feel really satisfying to the fans just to have his presence there. And I’m sure everybody wants more of it. Who wouldn’t? He’s delightful. But we take what we can get.”

That was similar to what Paget Brewster (Prentiss) previously told us. “He does come back to the team when he is needed, and that I think is something that the fans are going to be really excited about. I think they’re going to be very happy to see why Reid pops up and how that story plays out,” she hinted.

Our first thought is, of course, the aftermath of JJ’s (A.J. Cook) husband dying, but we’re still early in the season and so much more could happen. After all, the team is still dealing with Voit (Zach Gilford) and his serial killer network, and we can’t help but think that they could really use Reid’s brain for that.

What do you think is going to bring back Matthew Gray Gubler as Reid? What are you hoping to see from that episode? Let us know in the comments section below.

Criminal Minds: Evolution, Thursdays, Paramount+




Conversation10 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. O

    OrangeGuitar

    Would love to see Morgan back also

    9 1

    1. R

      RedBulb

      Especially since his television show on CBS has been cancelled.

      1

      1. G

        GreenBone

        Yes, SWAT was canceled but I just now read that a spinoff of SWAT is being planned with Shemar Moore to Star as Hondo. I would really love for him to come back to criminal minds though.

  2. O

    OrangeGuitar

    I would love to see him back and with jj

    9 5

  3. O

    OliveClover

    I hope he and Max the art teacher are a couple, because they were ADORABLE. I hope they’ve created kooky collaborative art in their spare time, and that they cuddle up and watch Doctor Who and go to museums together because Spencer deserve Nice Things

    3 1

  4. G

    GreenCupcake

    Back for JJ

    6 4

  5. G

    GreenButton

    I hope Reid comes back permanently and someday eventually him & JJ get together ❤️

    4 3

  6. B

    BlueBox

    No disrespect to his fans

    I think the show has somewhat been improving since he left

    I kinda hope Shemar Moore could make some occasional appearances since his other CBS show is about to come to an end

  7. G

    GoldButterfly

    Yeah, I love Dr. Reid, but Matthew deserve better.

    1

  8. G

    GoldPizza

    Why would any of the original cast members want Shemar to return to Criminal Minds? Think about it... They already have a large ensemble cast to give screen time to. Shemar returns and things will once again become all about Shemar. They're probably already enjoying a drama free, connected, team effort on the show. If Shemar comes back that will surely change. He will bring with him his narcissistic, entitled, chip on his shoulder attitude. He will disrupt the harmony and screen time for all will be reduced to placate him. Cast and crew all remember how things were before. At this point, they should know better. They don't have to put up with him. Should Shemar return, I'll be streaming reruns of GILLIGAN'S ISLAND instead.

    1 8