‘American Idol’s Eliminated Semi-Finalists Speak Out on Being Cut Just Before Finals
Spoiler Alert
American Idol‘s Disney-themed night wasn’t so magical for two of the singing competition semi-finalists.
Singers John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix were announced as the Season 23 finalists on Monday night. That meant crooners Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis ended their quest to become the next American Idol.
TV Insider, along with a small group of reporters, spoke with Nalley and Artis following last night’s live broadcast to get their thoughts on their Idol journey and their plans for the future. Both were filled with nothing but thanks for having gone so far in the competition.
“I feel good,” Nalley said. “Right now, I’m just super grateful for all that has come to me.”
“I’ve got a lot of exciting things coming up,” he adds. “I’m going to hit the ground running. I’m going to keep being me. I’m going to stop singing other people’s songs, and I’m going to write my own. I’ll play those and hope that’s enough. I’m ready to take this to the next level, for sure.”
Disney / Christopher Willard
Nalley says he’s learned a good deal about himself from embarking on this journey. “Idol taught me that I can be who I want to be,” he says. “I feel now that I’ve ‘graduated,’ I’ve learned some very valuable lessons. It’s pretty amazing being in the Top 5.”
“I learned from Lin [Manuel Miranda, guest mentor] how to connect with the audience more and step into the theatrical side of things,” Nalley adds.
“I felt like I went out there and I gave it the best that I could,” Artis says. “It was such a beautiful night to be able to do a second round of Disney songs. It was so special. Getting a standing ovation for both of them was just a blessing.”
Like Nalley, Artis feels grateful to have been a semi-finalist. “I didn’t get the answer that I wanted tonight, but I’m still blessed to be in the position that I am in,” he says. “I’m just thankful that God has brought me through this journey and I got to get up there and do what I love to do in front of people that I love. I’m just excited for what come’s next.”
Artis says he’s incredibly happy he was able to performer his original songs on the show including “Out of the Blue” on Mother’s Day. “I think it was Luke [Bryan, American Idol judge] who said, ‘We usually get worried when someone does their own song,’ but when he heard I was going to this, he said, ‘Wow, I can’t wait to hear this,’” Artis says. “That’s the sort of validation that really empowers me to go forward in my artistry. I worked really hard as a song writer, but also a performer to create good material that connects with my heart and soul. To see that America really enjoyed that just fills me with gratitude. I can’t say anything beyond that.”
Artis adds that he already feels like a winner because he’s been able to perform in front of millions of American Idol viewers on a weekly basis. “That’s what every artist strives for – to have an audience,” he says.
Both semi-finalists will be back for next week’s finale. And both plan on voting for the next American Idol. Nalley’s keeping mum about who’s getting his vote. So is Artis.
“I don’t know which [finalist will get my vote],” Artis muses. “I’m going to base [my vote] on performance. I want to hear the songs. I want to see the performances. I know all of them have so much talent. I just want to see them deliver. They’ve delivered day after day. If someone makes me cry, then that person will get my vote! Let’s go!”
American Idol, Season 23 Finale, Sunday, May 18, 8/7c, ABC
Hit All the High Notes
Get absolutely everything about American Idol in your inbox!
Conversation169 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
C
I'm really tired of American Idol choosing country singers. John's voice can't compare to Thunderstorm or Jamal or Brianna's voices. They are the real talent this season. Carrie saying to John last night "You just might win this thing" was unfair to the other contestants... particularly because the others are better singers and better performers.
133 35
-
R
Her comment was no more out of place than what I've heard Luke say, or what Simon said to Carrie all those years ago.
42 3
-
R
Correct. Simon told Carrie the same thing (and he was obviously correct) and even said she would likely outsell all the previous winners at that time. Not sure if she outsold Kelly Clarkson but they are both superstars.
1
-
-
G
Actually John is from Louisiana , he has strong southern roots and singing songs he loves. This is the first season i watched American Idol, i have been impressed with a lot of preformers. I just do not see a need to criticize , musical taste varies. I love country,but i like R and B, eighties . BReanna has done a lot of gospel and she rarely strays from the mike. Jamal and Thunderstorm are both great. I do miss Colby.the judges should not pick favorites, but does it not come down to who gets the votes
10 3
-
O
Gabby was the winner that didn't make it
17 5
-
R
I think jamal can win it.out of the top three he is the best. John is little inexperienced but the teenie poppers are going to vote for John because he's cute. Hopefully everyone votes for the best singer and performer. Hope it's Jamal
8 5
-
P
I'm 63 so I don't Qualify as teenie booper & Love John's true natural country sound. He's old country but I love Jamal ,Thunderstorm & Nalley also . These are favorites of all!
14
-
-
O
It's the people who choose country you can understand the words
9 1
-
C
I too, am tired of this being country idol. So, many singers have better voices than the country singers. If they are going to favor country singers, than name it country idol.
6 4
-
P
The last 2 winners in a row were not country
-
-
R
At the end of the day it’s not always the best singer that wins but the one who can establish a fan following. It’s who is going to sell records and fill up stadiums for concerts.
15
-
O
Bingo
3
-
-
G
It’s the public that’s choosing the finalists.
1 1
-
C
I think Blake Shelton, Reba, Luke and whoever else should have a country music show!! It will never be fair because a lot of America votes Country. So if they all have to go up against each other then the best country singer wins! But to put him against these r&b and and other genre, singers is really just unfair in my opinion. Go ahead. Tell me I'm wrong. It's an idea though.
1
-
O
I love country, but Jamal has my vote. He is my favorite. Honestly though, I thought Gabby was gonna win. Disappointed that she was eliminated, but America voted and it is what it is.
2
-
-
G
I so agree!
1
-
G
It’s not up to American idol to choose a winner it’s the viewers the judges pick them by voice when they audition they pick their own songs country or not
1 1
-
O
There are also several other great singers that were cut. American Idol utilizes audience voting To help determine who is going to be profitable. There are many great singers who don't have enough stage presence for audience appeal Which also sells records. Take Taylor Swift for example, not the best singer in the world vocally, but she has her own songs, and puts on a good show, and has great crowd appeal and that is why she is successful. it's not strictly about singing talent but the overall package. just because you have a great voice doesn't mean you will sell.
2
-
-
O
My top 3 was Breanna, Jamal, and Thunderstorm. If you go by voice alone then Breanna has the best voice I've heard in a long time. Jamal has the full package and Thunderstorm is a true artis(t).
John is ok but should have gone home a couple episodes ago...he can't match the other 3.
105 35
-
P
Breanna has been my favorite from the start. She's got a beautifulsinging voice and doesn't scream like some do. She's also very humble and doesn't act entitled. I do like John most of the time, but I have a feeling most of his votes are coming from young girls who are crushing on him!
116 16
-
C
Wrong, I'm old enough to be his grandmother and voted for John. I also voted for Breanna
8 3
-
P
I believe so too Breanne was really good they all did great
4 1
-
R
Exactly The young ones will vote for John which is so unfair.
1 4
-
G
Why is that so unfair! I'm 70 and crushin' on John too!
Had to learn how to vote! Lol
5 1
-
-
B
Breanna has a great voice but, is not current she also dresses like she is 50 . I know that shouldn't matter but. it does. You have to be current.
-
G
You are very wrong. Most of his votes are coming from his hometown people like me!
-
-
O
I agree. I voted for Thunderstorm, Jamal & Breanna. Lots of country fans voting. Hoping Thunderstorm gets a contract with someone.
7 1
-
G
Although I like Jamal the best 2nd is Thunderstorm and 3rd is Breanna, but I have to admit John is an excellent country singer; however, it's kind of challenging when it comes to different genre of music.
1
-
-
O
My selection to win overall was Gabby!! Now, I’m voting for Jamal. While the others are so very talented these two seem heads above with their vocal range and ability to sing different genres.
74 13
-
O
My only complaint in Jamal is he doesn't smile enough. He needs to look happy about what's going on and really look happy. He was my first yes, but now Thunderstorm beat him out in my opinion on charisma. I di hope all 5 get to make their mark. Also Gabby. She needs to be picked up to make her mark. She has what it takes.
27 5
-
P
I think all of the last 5 will get music deals, it's just to hard to pick because they are all so good. If I really had to pick one I'd have to say Jamal !
1
-
G
But Jamal's voice supercedes them all, he still smiles I just think he's nervous and just trying to absorb it all in for this is not easy, but his voice makes it easy.
1 3
-
O
I have said to that Jamal needs to smile more and move around more. I personally do not want to go watch someone that just stands there stone cold. He looks scared to death. Not saying he can’t sing. But you have to have stage presence and personality too.
2 1
-
O
You don't know where his emotions are he's singing. He maybe singing from a place if pain and sadness.
1 2
-
-
G
Yes, Gabby is amazing! Gabby and Thunderstorm were the best!
2
-
P
Gabby is a born Star, but so is Jamal. Jamal is going to change lives. Let's hope that people cast their votes for the right one and for the right reasons.
-
-
-
O
I honestly loved Slater! Thunderstorm was amazing too. Personally I love a voice that is raspy. I think John is sweet but kind of boring
76 23
-
O
I agree!
1 3
-
R
I liked John from the get-go, but somebody needs to get the boy a new hat. A nice felt Stetson would sit way better.
17 6
-
P
Slater much better singer!
4 7
-
G
That is his good luck charm. Sure hope he is not going bald!
-
G
I LOVE his hat! Did you hear him tell his story why he wears it ? Bent over looking at some tools in an Antique store in Texas. Raised up and hit his head. There was this old (he had a name for it)Straw hat. Wondered if it fit his weird head. It did. He's worn it on stage for the last 3 years when he started singing. I love ❤️ it
1 1
-
-
O
Thunderstorm and Slater were my favorites because of the uniqueness of their voices and style but the three that are left are good artists as well.
1
-
-
G
I really think they all did great. I tended to like the male singers though...choices of songs, THEIR singing, etc... However, they all deserve credit! John stole my heart...his,singing is great! Josh, Slater, Thunderstorm, and Jamal all sang really well....and really everhone did a great job this season!!! I give them credit!!!
They should all be proud!😁😁😁
66 15
-
G
I really want John Foster to win, but very disappointed that Thunderstorm Artis isn't in the top 3 he has an amazing voice. Thunderstorm should be there instead of either Brianna or Jamal.
82 33
-
O
He had a chance when he was on The Voice! Time to quit the reality shows.
5 3
-
R
Who?
-
C
Thunderstorm was on The Voice already and came in 3rd
-
-
P
God is in control. He is doing what he has been called to do. He is a true gift to this world. We are required to walk in our calling. Who are we to judge and say that someone is not deserving. It's because he has not given up that makes him stand out even more.
1 1
-
-
P
I think Jamal should’ve been knocked out. My three are Brianna, John and Thunderstorm.
53 30
-
P
I strongly disagree. Jamal is a whole package. God created this Star. He is a total package. He should win. If he doesn't win, it won't be because he wasn't the best. I've never seen a person more humble, talented and Blessed!!!
1
-
-
B
Instead of Breanna for sure.
2
-
P
I strongly disagree.
-
-
C
I was disappointed that they kept Brianna and Jamal.
I voted for Slater, John and Thunderstorm.
70 25
-
C
I had been voting Slater Thunderstorm and Gabby. They all had the best storytelling voices. It’s sad what this show has become. Go back on iTunes and watch an idol show. World’s different! Not a Disney tribute. Ridiculous
3 4
-
P
They were good. Gabby was Amazing and a true star, but you can't say that without giving Jamal his praises. This young man is the complete package. His voice and talent touches your heart and soul. God gave him everything needed to change lives.
1
-
-
G
I wanted slater or thunderstorm
12 5
-
G
I think they all are good; however, I think Jamal, then Thunderstorm and then John, but whomever win blessings to them, even the runner-ups got a chance to showcase their beautiful talent and perhaps will get a contract with someone.
1
-
-
G
All you can see when Jamal sings is teeth
2
-
C
But they are pretty white teeth as that🤷🏽♀️😁😁
1 2
-
P
Well at least we know he has some. Above that, he is the most gifted and talented singer and performer left on stage.
1
-
-
-
R
Nonsense. John is a good country singer, but Slater & Thunderstorm are on completely different levels.
43 6
-
J
IN MY OPINION the final three should have been the ones you listed above
2 1
-
-
O
I wanted Thunderstoem but now it’s Jamal for me!
49 16
-
O
Why?
-
-
C
I kind of like “under the biscuit” better. Living down south, I think I can start incorporating it into my vocabulary.
28
-
O
me too. lol
-
-
P
I Believe John is the whole package. I dont look at looks or genere its sound and show. He has the consistant sound and gets the audience better than others. I had the top 3 as as John, Jamal, and Thunderstrorm. They all are very good.
35 14
-
G
KLF, you and I are on the same page. John, Jamal and Thunderstorm were my best top three ever. Can you image if these three had their own show!!!!!! Absolutely through the roof!!!! I am still crying over Thunder getting eliminated but the silly people at Idol could not break tradition and have three males in the final. Of course, now Jamal will come in third and we get a male/femalle final. I wanted the three guys to be three winners this year - they are simply put TERRIFIC!
-
-
G
That’s what happens when Teenage girls see a cute boy on stage. They are the ones that voted the most I’m sure.
They See the person Not the music that they are playing.
People did not appreciate thunderstorm With his talent to write Creative songs.
But honestly, it’s probably best that he didn’t win so that he can venture out on his own and not be tied down by a contract.
People know about him now his name is out there. I’m sure he Will be moving forward with this carrier.
it should’ve been Gabby Slater and thunderstorm in the top three
37 17
-
G
Typo * career
-
O
He didn’t win The Voice either.
2 1
-
-
B
You can go to the strip in Nashville and hear at least half a dozen singers as good as John
2
-
-
O
Jamal all the way!!! I was very disappointed when Gabby was eliminated.
30 10
-
O
Gabby did too many runs for my taste. Got to be tiresome. Great voice but overkill in my opinion.
1
-
-
R
This season of American Idol had some Amazing singers many are not going to have a problem with getting signed. I am taken away by Jamal I followed him before American Idol and what you hear in is singing is his soul. The ability to tell a story amd make you feel the story telling. However John and Breanna both have Amazing voices. You can't please everyone that's why it is important to Vote!!!!
21 3
-
P
Nah, Thunderstorm was BY FAR the best! I'm done watching, now🤦♀️
25 11
-
O
I just knew that Thunderstorm would make it and I was shocked when he didn't make it in the top 3
21 6
-
-
O
If we have another country singer win I’m done with the show. They are so pushing John. It is annoying. Not fair with 2 country judges.
32 22
-
O
Watch the voice
2 2
-
O
Well its their target audience as country is huge. Not everyone like every genre and I am no country music fan but, enjoying the show and the singers is what its all about.
I think Jamal will win it all.
9 4
-
C
I hope you are right! I’m a Jamal fan too! But this show has always leaned towards the country genre,unfortunately!
1
-
-
O
Reading the comments it seems like the people are pushing John. Not me.
2 4
-
C
They are pushing DISNEY— it’s the stupid 13 year olds voting for John.
5
-
O
And 40 year olds who happen to love prime country & think he’s damn good at delivering it. This is American Idol, not The Voice. Those 13 year olds made Taylor Swift. The American Idol is that of the youth.
3 1
-
P
I am 66 and voted for John. He has stage presence and plays an instrument and writes songs. Over-all more & multi-talented
3 1
-
-
-
P
Im socked that Slated and Thunderstorm were eliminated! What is America looking for ? I can’t see any of the remaining as THE American Idol. When the show starts at 8:00 pm here on the west coast, the voting is already closed and we haven’t even the performances yet! Rethink your platforms ABC!!
12 3
-
O
Hands down the best artist is thunderstorm but the beat vocals was Canan hill come on now yall know nobody could out sing him for real
22 13
-
O
I love Canan. I was shocked to see him go home so soon.
-
-
G
John has been getting on my nerves. I feel like his ego has taken over, gotten a little smug, like it's in the bag for him already. He has his own thing for sure, but he is not the best singer in the competition, not even close.
12 5
-
T
Some people call it stage presence and confidence. Others call it being smug.
3 2
-
-
O
I love Jamal, Thunderstorm, Breanna. I like John too. I think whatever happens all of them will go far. God bless each of them and all the rest booted off earlier.
8 1
-
O
Well Breanna is kinda boring and Carrie was spot on with her critique
11 4
-
G
Breanna has grown , all the finalists are great. But i like both John and Jamal better
5
-
G
John is my favorite, clean cut, pure country, a southern gentleman, a young George Strait
9 4
-
G
I agree, I thought they were all mean to Breanna and she truly has the must beautiful voice. Shame on them for doing that.
6 1
-
P
I felt like the judges don’t like Breanna and are favoring the boys this season. They hardly ever give her a really good compliment.
7 2
-
P
I don't agree, they have gave her lots of compliments ! ! I didn't like it when Carrie told Jamal he needed to walk around more on Sunday and a lot of the others that sang in place she didn't say anything. Dont get me wrong I really like Carrie, I just didn't like that.
4 1
-
O
None of us liked that comment
1
-
-
-
O
Love the personality & singing of John & Slater, Thunderstorm has an amazing voice, love his growl & smile. Breanna is beautiful with a voice to match & Jamal is so good at R&B, but I want to see him connect more with the audience and let us see more of his personality in his performances. Love this season!!
5 1
-
G
I liked Thunderstorm on the Voice better. Someone musta told him to GROWL...And I don't care for it
-
-
M
Slater and thunderstorm should have gotten to be seen during their elimination!! They were my top 2 from the beginning! I still don’t understand why they didn’t air them leaving. I’m disappointed with this part! Absolutely love how they all were able to get a single but I truly see slater going super far in this music world! I also see or would love to see him and Carrie Underwood sing a song he writes and it blow up and take top songs worldwide. Just my thoughts and personal opinions!
Thunderstorm will also do things! Good intentions and good hearts to put messages out to people from these fine young fellers! #teamslater! #thatsallihavetosayaboutthat
2
-
G
I've heard Foster's voice a hundred times on cruise boats or bars. Good but not worth of a record deal. He may go a year with little young girls holding him up but it won't last...Sorry not that vocally good
4 2
-
O
I like the biscuit.
2
-
G
I think they were all very very talented in their own way. It takes great courage to "think" you might have a singing talent and then step up for such a program as this. So many try out each year. This is the handful that got their chance to show the world what they had for a range of vocal abilities, stage prescence, and confidence. They all have very different tones, styles, and performed best in different genres. Each week I was surprised to see some one with what I thought had more talent then one that stayed, leave- Gabby leaving with Thunderstorm staying last week was a shocker to me. But it's what the voters are enjoying for their own entertainment or seems. John is very gifted with country. Country never seems to die, and he's a young heartthrob. Jamal is to myself very very gifted and has no difficulty stepping into different genres. Brianna has come a long way but, I don't know if she will hold her spot between Jamal and John. It's nothing to get annoyed with though. After all.... it's entertainment all around.
2
-
C
Jamal is very outstanding, he is happy about his career. He smiles as he performs. He shows his pearly white teeth and he is a good to dresser. I like the other two, but Jamal really stands out above them. To be honest.
2 2
-
-
R
I honestly think John Foster is not top 3. He does not have a voice that is relatable to young listeners.
10 8
-
P
The comment is very judgemental. God is the only Judge. Who are we tojudge, discredit and degrade others. This young man is the most gifted person I've seen in a long time. What you see is God's Anointing on this young man. God has Blessed him with so much talent. His humbleness, heart, passion and genuineness shows every time he hits the stage. We can choose who we want you win, but let's not do it while degrading others because of our own personal reasons.
1
-
P
The comment is very judgemental. God is the only Judge. Who are we to judge, discredit and degrade others. This young man is the most gifted person I've seen in a long time. What you see is God's Anointing on this young man. God has Blessed him with so much talent. His humbleness, heart, passion and genuineness shows every time he hits the stage. We can choose who we want to win, but let's not do it while degrading others because of our own personal reasons.
1
-
-
T
All the contestants have been great this season, but they all have their niche. While she has a great voice, I think any vote for Breanna is a waste. I don't believe that she has the desire for success that would have her leave her children and husband for long hours and days at a time. I predict that win or lose, within 12 to 18 months, she will be back home singing in her church every Sunday and occasionally singing the national anthem at local sports events. She talks and acts like a trad wife...
1
-
C
At this point ( and at the top 8) they all showed incredible and diverse talent. Winning Idol is not everything. Consider Jennifer Hudson. Your gift will make room for you. The important thing is they stay true to themselves before God. Communicate life and healing through song. They are all capable of doing so.
1
-
P
I feel thunderstorm was great would buy his album of songs really wanted him to win
6 5
-
G
I just don't get all the hoo-ha over John. I find him both boring to watch and boring to listen to. Any of the other 4 - Jamal, Breanna, Thunderstorm and Slater - are much better performers and vocalists. Just don't get it. I REALLY hope either Jamal or Breanna takes the win, instead of not-so-awesome John that all the little girls are swooning over (why? No idea).
-
O
Jamal is the winner rather voted winner or not of Idol.
-
T
I think American Idol and shows like The Voice are prejudice and will,pick whoever they want. They always do
-
P
I see so many people saying that it's always a white country singer that wins. You do realize that the last 2 winners in a row were not white country singers, right?
-
C
MAGA Underwood did not stand up for Thunderstorm despite his amazing performances for one obvious reason. Racism
-
A
I feel like they all have done amazing. However after reading all these comments, I may be wrong. Aren't the votes from the fans what determines who wins and not the judges?
I admire the singer's that got on stage and were not ashamed to show their faith. They all have came a long way since the beginning. This is the first American Idol that I've watched since Carrie Underwood was on the show. I hate it for the ones that had to go home, but I feel like they will all will go far. Good luck to the final 3
-
B
It should have been John Thunderstorm and Slater in that order 1 2 3.
-
G
Why have Carrie's outfits been so weird this season?
-
G
Right now country music is the
Most Popular. Reason Beyoncé, Jelly Roll and that
Other guy with steel
All Over his teeth came to
Country from rock.
All are good and
The top 3 will get some kind
Of record deal.
-
L
Carrie should be eliminated as a judge! She's clearly biased. She complained that Jamal didn't move enough but gushed and praised John when he sat the entire time!
-
O
That is what has made the season so entertaining as each singer was soooooo different and ALL GREAT!!! Truly a tough decision as they're all winners.
-
C
American Idol is about voting. When I vote, I notice that most of the time my selected contestants progress to the next level. I am a witness to this. If you are not voting, then you are considered a spectator whether than a participator. Spectators fail to become involved, but will critique. I encourage you to participate if you would like to see your favorite move forward.(I had continued to give Thunderstorm the maximum votes each time.I am certain that these votes aided in him moving as far as he did in the competition. Had these who are now claiming that he should be in the finals voted, he would have been in the finals as my votes obviously were not enough. ) As the saying goes, put your money where your mouth is.
-
T
I feel like it’s a popularity contest! It should be about talent and how well they sing! I have seen so many great artists go home and ones that should have left long ago, go on to finals! Then when the wrong person wins because of popularity they don’t get continued contracts because they can’t sing or produce songs that sell! It’s a shame! It’s not about who is cute, or who is pretty or even who has the sad story! Come on people!!! Vote for who has the talent as a whole!!!! Who deserves it and whose music you want to hear on the radio!! Vote wisely people!!!
-
O
What I think really doesn’t matter, but Breanna should have gone weeks ago, too boring. She has a lovely voice but her stage presence sucks.
-
O
My top two would have been Gabby and John. Totally different but both top to me.
John has been my fav from the start.
-
C
I think they should completely do away with Disney night, not everyone cares for the themes or music regarding Disney. Not my favorites for any of the contestants
-
G
If you put a cowboy hat on, you will win. That guy is terrible. Thunderstorm shouldn't have been eliminated. It is bullshit.
-
R
I voted for John, Brianna, and Thunderstorm. So I got 2 out of 3.
-
R
If it weren’t for all the teeny boppers on social media John foster wouldn’t still be in it
-
R
Jamal should not have moved forward to the final 3…Thunderstorm Artis was far better and was more soulful and emotional in his performance and should have been the third finalist. Breanna has a beautiful voice! And she has the range and heart to win this. But…John has been consistently on the mark…when he sang “ I Cross My Heart “(my favorite George Strait song) he put his heart and soul into the song. You could feel and hear the sincerity in bids delivery. Also don’t forget “Tell That Angel I Love Her”. I believe all of the remaining top 5: Jamal. John. Thunderstorm, Breanna, and Slater will have great success if all continue to push forward with their ambitions. Good luck and cheers to all.
-
R
John is the sweet boy loves the Lord gives God credit there's no doubt that he is precious young man it appears however he is really doesn't invoke any excitement or wow that was amazing song ever not once he should not have been there every time I cut came I thought well John is gone and it's ridiculous that he's made it this far he might do well on the voice but not here Slater thunderstorm and Brianna definitely better than John definitely more wow factor on them three you never came away from any of John's songs and said you know that knocked my socks off but you did on Slater thunderstorm Brianna and Jamal tomorrow's going to win it and he deserves it
-
R
Carrie underwood should have never said you could win this thing to John and there is no comparison of Simon saying it to her years ago because there is no comparison between her and John so it wasn't a leg up for Simon to say that her competition wasn't there as competition her success explains it it was easy to say you could win this and she certainly deserved it John is nowhere near as talented is carried by any stretch of the imagination and will more than likely fade off into nowhere land however thunderstorm and Slater certainly thunderstorm the most are definitely better than John I can't stand the fact that they pick country people too how about let's pick it for the freaking Talent is it ridiculous or what Jamal's going to win it anyway and would have wanted a thunderstorm and Slater were there Jamal is the American Idol
-
G
JF had me from the start! Nix is too much Mom. Underwood sux!
3 3
-
B
I definitely agree about Carrie!
1 1
-
B
I am very happy, my three favorites are the top three, but now I have no idea who to choose, they are all really good in their own way and I love them all.
-
C
I think all the little 13 year olds girls that vote on this stupid show don’t have a clue what they’re doing! They’ll probably vote boring as hell John to win. I’ve tried to give Idol a chance but I’m out. This show is so commercialized and is far from what it used to be I just can’t anymore! Disney? Really? They should be able to sing WTF they want and not be made to promote Disney! Slater could be like the next Dylan, Gabby the next Whitney, and Thunderstorm the next whoever! They were all unique and great storytellers when they sang. The rest are predictable and boring ( although Brenna has a good voice but sounds like so many others). I just don’t care enough to vote or watch any longer. Go back and watch Staler and Thunderstorm’s auditions and tell me the best are still there.
2 2
-
D
It doesn't matter to me who wins. There'll so talented I truly believe the future holds incredible opportunities for each of them.
-
J
I thought putting Disney Night as the semi-finals was a bad choice. I am sure Disney demanded it because the audience numbers would be up for a semi-final, but the choice of songs available is dismal and in general, did not show off the singers' range. The one song that grabbed me was Ain't No Mountain High Enough, a wonderful song written by Marvin Gaye, which was so different from the rest. I felt that many of the singers' talents were sabotaged by this theme.
1
-
O
Hands-down, I think Jamal Roberts should take it all, but I won’t hold my breath because I’ve been around long enough to know how to stay works. And I remember thunderstorm from The Voice. He has a great voice also
1
-
O
I really thought it would be Jamal and Gabby at the end. They are both the best to me. I also liked Slater and Thunderstorm.
1
-
-
L
Sk, nope, she DID throw Jamal under the bus. Told him he needed to move when she gushed and praised John who sat his entire song. She needs to be replaced.
1
-
G
I think Thunderstorm is awesome. His smile alone, is captivating. And his voice is amazing. He should have been in the three finalists.
1
-
C
Breanna has a powerful voice, pretty and I really think she will go far. She sings harder songs than John.
Johns voice is nice, but he doesn't go out of his comfort zone. His voice is always sung the same way. No sparks!
1
-
R
AI almost always gets their finale wrong. Whereas, The Voice gets it right. I know people will down vote, but if Idol got it right more often there'd be more than just 2 stars from the long running show.
Slater & Thunderstorm should be in the finale, they were the 2 best performers, hands down.
1
-
G
Thunderstorm came in 3rd on the Voice 5 years ago then Covid hit and they couldn't play live
-
-
R
John has that old time country swoon George straight reminds me of Dwight yokum they were all really good this year it’s hard to pick at the end
1
-
R
As a professional guitarist and musician, I definitely called bs on this whole american idol, because gabby should have won... No one was even in her league.She sang whitney houston, barbara streisand and beyonce, give me a break...
1
-
B
The right choice
1
-
G
I’m done watching! Thunderstorm and Slater going home over Jamal and John, No Way!!!!! The most talented people went home. I could care less who wins now.
1
-
P
I liked john at the begining but then realized it seems like he doesnt really play the guitar. Slater plays way better and a lot more. My top 2 were Thunderstorm and Gabby. So now I hope its Breanna maybe Jamal. Not really here for John because he seems meh and with the not playing the guitar but using it as a prop really turns me off.
4 5
-
G
He only started playing guitar and singing 3 years ago...
-
-
O
I think thunderstorm and Slater should of been in the top three with Breanna
5 6
-
O
I think Carrie gives the best advice that she came to everyone and he’s honest and fair. If she is she tries to help everybody she’s been there done that and the best edit.
3 4
-
P
My favorites have been Gabby, Jamal and Thunderstorm. I truly believe that they have the best voices.
John is adorable and he knows it!
Is is a good singer but there's nothing special about him.
Breanna has a beautiful voice but I believe that her limiting herself to gospel music just doesn’t cut it.
SO, Jamal should be the winner, in my opinion
2
-
C
Really miss both Thunderstorm and Slater. The final three are all very talented, but when Jamal sings, I can such soul and decades from the past as well as energy, strength and excitement. Jamal brings true meaning into the words he sings. Thunderstorm did that too. Takes a true heart to be able to do that.
2
-
P
Slater Nallley is by far the best talent on the show and as most have done the one who wins American Idol will not be as successful as the runner ups!
9 11
-
B
Both were incredibly talented. So much talent this season. It's just the beginning. I can't even tell u who has won over the years. Love Slater I must admit. Best of luck to all
2 4
-
R
Slater, Thunderstorm & John should have been the top three finalists as most everybody was hoping for this scenario, I voted for these three of course.
2 5
-
O
Glad thunderstorm is out. He’s already got a following from The Voice. Time to give the reality shows a rest. That’s two he’s not won. Just my opinion.
3
-
B
Let's be real. Nobody can out sing Jamal. At all. Thunderstorm was great though, really liked him. But we know how this usually plays out so.
3 6
-
G
I really enjoyed watching Slater his voice was incredible! I was definitely hoping to watch him in the Finale with John. All the singers were Amazing. Looking forward to seeing who wins.
4
-
B
I probably will not watch Idol anymore. Clearly the audience is not choosing the best singer. Brianna definitely should not be in the final 3. Sorry Idol but I am done
4
-
O
But she had that super cute baby to win over the judges... I thought Mattie had the best voice of the girls but I do think the guys have stronger voices this year.
1
-
-
P
Slater was best and Thunderstorm. I would have cut Foster and Jamal.
8 13
-
B
John Foster absolutely not he looks like a school shooter, creepy as heck and soooo mediocre! The only talent left is Jamal! Slater and Thunderstorm should be in the final with him! So sick of these mediocre country stars you never hear from again! But with 2 country on the panel no shock horrors here! Carrie gotta go she is so plastic and false awful
2 12
-
R
If you can’t say anything nice it would be best if you said nothing at all
4
-
R
I love country music but not John Foster. Too old school now a days. Should be Breanna, Slater and Thunderstorm
2 5
-
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services