11 Terrible Shows With Great Ratings

Sometimes broadcast networks hit it big with TV shows that are just as much a hit with viewers as they are with critics. (Think The West Wing, The Simpsons, House, et cetera.) And sometimes, shows that are a hit with viewers get raked over the coals by critics.

The shows below, for example, all ranked among broadcast TV’s top-rated programs for multiple seasons… even though professional or armchair critics gave them poor marks. Here are some of the TV’s most popular and most derided shows.

11
10
9
8
7
6
Dharma & Greg
5
Extreme Makeover: Home Edition
4
3
2
1
American Idol

Conversation6 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.

  1. R

    Reader

    Well, this list is NOT wrong about Walker,Texas Ranger and the 2 "reality" shows on this list. While American Idol has had SOME idols, as it were, their track record is largely trash. All "reality" shows are trash and should be left on the floor, where they belong.

  2. R

    Reader

    Absolutely! It was a great show. I just rewatched them all on Hulu recently.

  3. R

    Reader

    Stop shouting!

  4. J

    John M. Williams

    So the public are a bunch of idiots? The producers are crying all the way to the bank. I will agree the Falcon Crest did take a wierd trun in the second to last season.

  5. R

    Reader

    I SAID WHAT I WANT WHENEVER I WANT.

  6. R

    Reader