‘Hope Valley: 1874’ Finale: Cast Teases Season 2 After Love Triangle Cliffhanger

Just when it seemed that Hope Valley: 1874‘s love triangle between Olivia (Roan Curtis), Alexander (Lachlan Quarmby), and Clayton (Jedidiah Goodacre) would finally come to a head during the Season 1 finale, a shocking arrest interrupted Rebecca’s boarding house opening party. Now, it’s unclear where any of the When Calls the Heart prequel characters stand heading into Season 2.

Heading into the Season 1 finale, Hearties were more eager than ever to find out which way Olivia’s heart would pull her: Towards Alexander, the captivating Mountie who just arrived in town, or Clayton, the kindhearted blacksmith who’s been her friend forever? To answer that question, sat down with Swooon to break down the gripping Season 1 finale and tease what is to come for their characters during Season 2. (Spoilers ahead!)