‘Are You My First?’ Season 1: Are Any of the Virgin Couples Still Together?

Colton Underwood, Kaitlyn Bristowe, Rachael, Michael, Brooklyn, and Layne on Are You My First?
Hulu
Hulu
This excerpt appears
courtesy of our partner site

[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for Are You My First? Season 1.]

August 18, 2025, marked Hulu’s first time… dropping a virgins-only romance reality TV show.

Season 1 of Are You My First? featured 21 adults between 23 and 34 who have never done the dirty. Searching for lasting love, these virgins hit the beach looking for “the one” — or, the first one — at least. Among the cast were a former contestant from The Bachelorette, a stand-up comedian, an NFL cheerleader, and more.