Who’s the Killer on ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer?’ (POLL)

Ashley Moore in I Know What You Did Last Summer
Michael Desmond/Amazon Studios

[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for the first four episodes of I Know What You Did Last Summer.]

The Amazon series based on Lois Duncan’s 1973 novel I Know What You Did Last Summer won’t end the same way as the 1997 film… unless there’s a lot more going on than meets the eye.

The streaming service released the first four episodes of  the show at once, and in the premiere a group of teens accidentally hit a classmate, who dies from her injuries. Lennon (Madison Iseman) was driving, Dylan (Ezekiel Goodman), Johnny (Sebastian Amoruso), Riley (Ashley Moore), and Margot (Brianne Tju) were passengers, and the victim was Lennon’s twin Allison… or was it? As is revealed, the others thought Lennon was driving, and Allison didn’t correct them — and then she goes on to live as her sister (with her dad helping her do so!). Oh, and Lennon might not have been dead when they put her body in a cave for the tide to sweep away, if Riley did see her breathing.

Jump forward a year later, and Allison is still living as Lennon when she returns home from college, and she and the others find themselves being stalked by someone who claims to know what they did. What follows in the first four episodes is a series of murders. Among the victims: Johnny, as he’s trying to save his fiancé Eric and after he may or may not have picked up on “Lennon” smoking just like Allison used to; Dale (Spencer Sutherland), the friends’ prime suspect since he saw them on the road that night; and one of the cops on the case.

In the film, it was the original victim who was stalking the teens. However, Lennon’s body is found and laid to rest in Episode 4, eliminating her as the killer (probably). Clara (Brooke Bloom) did have her body “about a year,” she tells the twins’ father, Bruce (Bill Heck). Could Lennon have still been alive in the beginning and planned this all with Clara? It’s possible, but probably not likely.

The first four episodes have already hinted at other potential suspects. There’s Eric’s ex-wife, Kelly (Chrissie Fit), though even if she wanted him dead, why would she target the others? There’s Dylan, who’s been acting kind of suspicious and did, it turns out, feel the same way Allison did about him — only he slept with Lennon that night — and does think she’s the one who’s dead. Margot went to the bathroom a bit before the killer’s latest two victims were found there in Episode 4, which showed her complicated relationship with Lennon. Who knows how she might react to the truth about which twin died? Yes, we saw both of them get the video of Johnny’s head being chopped off, but could either of them be working with someone?

Bruce did see Johnny with Allison on the beach; maybe he targeted the teen when he did, after realizing he could reveal their secret (with Allison’s smoking), before he could finish his plan. Yes, this would be super dark to have him tormenting his daughter, but there is the matter of which daughter he preferred… And hey, maybe it turns out that Allison and Lennon have another sister out there (triplets!) who’s somehow involved.

But who do you think it is? Vote in our poll below.

I Know What You Did Last Summer, Fridays, Amazon Prime Video




Conversation18 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. G

    GoldCocktail

    It’s the real Lennon. She actually didn’t die in the car accident, was saved by Clara and planned to get revenge on the real Alison (who was driving the car). When Alison returns to town, Lennon and Clara abduct her and Lennon pretends to be Alison pretending to be Lennon! Then they kill Alison and the rest of the crew

    3

  2. G

    GoldCar

    It’s Lennon/Allison. She suffered a mental breakdown from living as another person and now suffers from a dual personality. It’s a twist on the original (where the original murder victim is the killer) Allison is the alleged victim but is actually alive and killing.

    3

    1. G

      GreenCupcake

      That make sense!!

  3. O

    OliveLocomotive

    The dad!

    2

  4. G

    GoldTrumpet

    Its Margot. She loved Lennon so she'd know Alison isn't her. Plus she had a mental breakdown and is unstable.

    But the killer did the spider honey ritual on Clara. Dylan and dad are the only cult members.

    Maybe dad n Dylan together.

    Lol who do u suspect least?

    Of the group, I say margot.

    of the whole cast, I say Sheriff Lyla. It's a RIVETING mystery!!!!

    1

  5. O

    OrangePumpkin

    It's 100% the cop.

    1

    1. O

      OrangePumpkin

      main, female cop i mean

      1. O

        OliveBeer

        Why Is that so

  6. B

    BlueCactus

    The dad

  7. R

    RedFlask

    Bruce. He’s protecting the secret with all his posibilities

  8. O

    OrangeCoathanger

    My thoughts exactly!

  9. C

    CyanCoathanger

    Ironic you say the killer is Bruce, Batman. 😂

  10. O

    OrangeLamp

    The dad killed the cop and the restaraunt owner to protect Lennon/Alison after she was out of character in front of them. Margot and Kyle are killing everyone else as part of her “therapy”. I don’t know how the spiders tie in.

  11. O

    OliveUmbrella

    It's Dylan because he loves Allison and want to revenge her death (as he thinks Allison is dead)

  12. G

    GoldFlame

    It's Bruce. He is killing everyone who could discover his daughter's secret. Yes he is tormenting Allison too, but it remains, for me, the most luckly answer

  13. B

    BlueLocomotive

    It’s the dad

  14. R

    RedCarrot

    The mom who left

    1

  15. P

    PurplePizza

    It's Riley.

    1