‘Survivor 51’: Lewis Kelly Reveals Season-Long Beef With Mike That Wasn’t Shown
What To Know
- Lewis Kelly was eliminated in Survivor 51 Episode 9 after losing a coin flip that could have won him immunity and increased the prize money.
- Lewis says his largely unaired distrust of Mike Pinsky influenced his decision to flip, as Mike had urged him not to take the risk.
- Lewis also reveals that he was disqualified from his final immunity challenge in a deleted scene.
The luck of the Irish did not show up for TikTok star Lewis Kelly in Survivor 51 Episode 9. The coin flip from Survivor 50 returned in the November 18 episode, but he had the opposite results of Rick Devens‘ coin flip that increased the 50 prize pot to $2 million.
After much deliberation at tribal council (and we mean a lot — Lewis tells TV Insider that he kept the cast there for “hours” as he debated whether or not to take on the challenge), Lewis’ Survivor journey ended with the wrong call in heads or tails. With this twist, the person flipping the coin either wins immunity and adds funds to the prize money, or they’re eliminated from the game. Lewis got the short end of the stick.
The 29-year-old competitor tells TV Insider that Mike Pinsky was the deciding factor in his choice to take the risk of elimination. A season-long rivalry had been raging between Lewis and Mike, but it wasn’t really shown this season. He tells TV Insider all about it in our exit interview below, and he also reveals that he was actually disqualified from his final immunity challenge after Devin Way pointed something out to Jeff Probst.

Robert Voets/CBS
You controlled your elimination, so how are you feeling about it many months later?
Lewis Kelly: It’s bittersweet. I mean, I had a phenomenal time out there. I was never anticipating in a million years to get that far. I though I would’ve been the first or second boot, so I can’t really complain. And the coin didn’t go in my favor, but I had such a good time. I had so much f***ing fun. It was unbelievable.
Did you think you would be first or second boot before the game started or was that because you were in Exile?
No, before the game was started, because I said to myself [that] I’m willing to go out there and play as soon as my feet hit the f***ing sand, give it a crack, balls to the wall, go for it. I knew a gameplay style like that would probably get a big target on my back and probably send me packing pretty early, but I was like, “I’d rather go out first or second than not do anything and make it far down the line.'” So, I was very, very much prepared to be an early boot.
How did going into Exile immediately change that?
Well, it saved me from being the first boot, that’s for sure.
It did, but I mean your feelings about your chances of getting out early.
I was scheming on Exile. I was plotting. I mean, it was miserable. I was there for 72 hours. I was there for three days alone. And on a 26-day game, that’s a long time. I came back from Exile and I feel like I had a really good lay of the land who was working with each other. I had a very untainted perspective of the game, of where the lines were drawn. I feel like it was kind of a blessing and a curse. It was a curse in the fact that I never really got that number one or number two relationship. I was everyone’s number three or four. And it’s like if people wanted to keep me around, they would keep me around. But I had a really good perspective of what was going on because I wasn’t in the middle.
I wasn’t lied to. In the first vote out, Kilby thought Jelly was with him and I was like, “She’s not with you.” And they’re thinking Brady’s on their side. And so I think Exile granted me a very interesting perspective on the game.

Robert Voets/CBS
Is there anything that happened during Exile that you wish had been shown in the episodes? Because you were there for a long time by yourself, but we only saw a glimpse of it.
You got enough because nothing happened because it was hell on earth. I mean, they had a secret scene of me making my pot-handle idol. They have a secret scene of me searching for idols, going mad. But realistically, that ax chopping bit, once that came in, it really exhausted me. I was so dehydrated. I couldn’t hold down water. I vomited five or six times during that challenge. And after that challenge, I actually collapsed. Medical came in and I could not stand for 24 hours after that challenge because every time I would stand up, I was reeling, so there wasn’t much to show.
Was it the heat that was getting you down? I mean, of course the challenge was really exhausting and your hands got so blistered, so not downplaying the intensity of that, but what other things were influencing that?
The heat was savage, especially coming from Ireland. It’s ruthless out there. I would say the heat is physical on your body. You’re not eating. Also, the isolation is just, mentally, it’s so much torture. And also, one thing is exile is a rotten beach, and the thing is, it’s very much on a slant, so even when you’re sleeping, you’re sleeping on a kind of slant, and you can never really get comfortable in exile. You could sleep on the rocky beach, or you can sleep in the jungle, but the jungle’s a hill, so it’s kind of disorienting regardless of the challenge. That was tough.
Yeah, all of your senses were just being brutalized.
That’s when the survivor element hit me. I was like, “Wait, how do I get fire? I don’t have a shelter.” I’m like, “Oh, crap.” And it’s not like it was a night. I’ve never seen a Survivor season with exile, except for 50. They had one night, so that was the mental torture of it. It was not knowing when does this end? Am I going to be here till the merge? One day passes, I’m still here. Two days pass, I’m still here. Three days, I’m still there, so it was just that kind of unknown, permanent uncertainty.
On tele, you only see the strategic, the challenges, the tribals. There’s a lot of hours in between that, and it’s all pure survival.
Yes, it’s rough. So, do you have any regrets about your choice to flip the coin? You were deliberating flipping it for a really long time.
In a way, I felt like it was my destiny to flip because no one was gunning for me at all. And this random day, everyone decides Lewis is the biggest threat. We need him out of the game. We go to the tribal, and it’s a coin flip. I’m like, “Wait, I was supposed to do this. This was my Survivor destiny.” I went home, but I don’t regret it.

Robert Voets/CBS
Was there any part of the deliberations that we didn’t see in this episode? You were going back and forth about it a lot. It was between you or Devin.
I kept them hostage there for hours [laughs]. We were there for two and a half hours. It was so cheeky. I was like, “There’s no rush. If I’m going home, I’m taking my time.” What you don’t see is I had a number one rule in the game. Number one rule was don’t trust Mike.
Don’t trust Mike?
And Mike stands me up and pulls me up for a one-on-one, and he was really the deciding factor of whether I should flip the coin or not, because Mike desperately does not want me to flip that coin. Mike is running through the statistics, the probability, the mathematics. He’s like, “If you do this, it’ll be 50-50, but if you don’t, then the probability rolls on.” And I’m like, “Oh, OK, so you don’t want me to flip the coin.” [The] fella’s giving me a spreadsheet, I’m like, “I do not need that right now. No one is going to flip the coin based on probability and mathematics.” I’m like, “I’m either just going to do it.”
Mike is really what sent me to flip the coin. It’s kind of sad that didn’t get shown in the edit because there’s so many people in there who have so much more to bring. Now, bear in mind, Mike, I still didn’t trust him, but that was so many people, like Cristian, I don’t think you guys realize he was probably one of the biggest threats in the game, so it’s really interesting to what gets shown and what doesn’t. But yeah, Mike was realistically one of the deciding factors to flip that coin.

Robert Voets/CBS
When did you establish your rule, “Do not trust Mike”? Clearly it was before this episode.
Oh my. OK, so I went through Carter’s bag, right? And I’m asking everyone, “Do you think I should tell Carter?” Because everyone’s so loose-lipped. Everyone one by one gives me their opinions, everyone offers me up their advice. I asked Mike, “Mike, do you think I should tell Carter I went through his bag?” Mike answers, “I don’t know. What do you think?” I said, “Oh no, I’m not trying to figure out what I think. I’m trying to get another perspective.” And he says, “Well, why don’t you weigh through the pros and the cons to me?”
I’m like, “No, no, no. I’ve already taught about the pros and cons. I want to get your fresh perspective on this.” He’s like, “OK, well tell me what’s going through your head.” I just rolled my eyes. I was like, “He is giving me nothing.” I looked at Patt, who was his number one. I rolled my eyes at her, and I went and told her, “I can’t work with Mike.” He gives me nothing. Ten minutes later, Mike walks over to me and is like, “I feel like I need to give you more.” And I’m like, “Patt, you snake!”
OK, so from that point on, you were just anti-Mike. And now he’s finally giving you an opinion in tribal council.
I did try to work with him prior to this.
After you decided not to trust him, but before this coin flip?
Yes, yes. I was like, “Mike, listen, here’s the day of the land. We have Devin and Jelly, we have Sharonda and Eric, we have Cristian and Carter, and we have Thien An and Maggie. These are all duos. Me and you, we don’t fit in any of these duos. Let’s eliminate one person from every single one of these duos.” He never took me up on my offer.
When did you pitch that to him? What episode was it?
I think it was the Brady vote-out. One of these merge vote-outs, I pitched it to him because I was like, “Listen, I want to play a flexible game as much as I don’t trust this fella. Why not? Why not just send it? Try something new.”

Robert Voets/CBS
And then given all that, he is telling you not to flip this coin in tribal council.
And I’m going to believe a word he says? [Laughs] No f***ing way. I mean, earlier that day I saw Mike, he’s a couple of feet away from me, talking to Carter. I can’t hear what they’re saying, but he’s like [gestures talking intensely]. And I’m like, “There’s only one reason you’d be talking to him that mad, and that would be if you’re trying to convince him to flip on me.” So, I was like, “Mike is not with me at all.” It was clear as day.
And you trusted that Carter was with you?
Carter and I were kind of like oil and water. Honestly, when I first met him, I pitched him, “I want to play a game. I want to play a crazy game. I want to just stab each other in the back. I want to have a fun game.” He shoots me straight. He says, “Honestly, I don’t want to play a game like that. I want to stick to a plan. I want to blindside people. I want to play a very alliance-based game.” And we left that first conversation when he joined us, and we left that, and we said, “All right, well, we’re not going to work together. OK, well, that’s that.” But I guess we fell for each other’s accents because it ended up coming to fruition. I wanted to think he was with me.
But at least he gave you some honest information, whereas Mike gave you nothing.
Yeah, yeah. I love Carter. Carter is the type of fellow who you guys don’t even realize how bloody funny he is. He has you cracking up laughing every second of the day.
Well, you’ve told me a lot of things that we did not see this season, but is there anything else you want to highlight that you wish we had gotten to see?
Oh, you know what? They had the rule on this [immunity] challenge [to] keep your backs to [to the slanted plank]. I was chilling, and my back apparently came off, and then Devin shouts to Jeff, “Jeff, Jeff, Jeff! Lewis’ back lifted! Lewis is back lifted!” Jeff didn’t even call it, and then Jeff [said] I got DQ’d [disqualified] from the challenge. I had so much more time in me, I felt.

Robert Voets/CBS
In the water challenge?
In the last one [before] I got eliminated, yeah.
Oh, so you sliding off of the plank was because you had to?
I just popped down, yeah. … Dev told me after [that he told Jeff about his back].
Oh, wow. OK.
Devin! Shut your mouth, Devin! [Laughs]
Clearly, people did not want you to get immunity.
Target was hot.
In this game where it’s all about social, political relationships, trying to convince people to let you stay, how do you feel about taking yourself out?
Oh, it’s brilliant. I would rather send myself home, take that extra million away from everyone who was gunning in for me. Sorry, you just don’t get it now. …Sorry, that extra mill’s coming home with me. I just embraced it. I embraced the chaos. I had so much fun, and I’d flip it again. I would.
Survivor, Wednesdays, 8/7c, CBS
Conversation1 Comment
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.
-
B
I loved Lewis! I was disappointed when he had to go!
