‘American Idol’ Top 5 Revealed, COVID Rears Ugly Head & Will.i.am Mentors (RECAP)
Spoiler Alert
American Idol celebrated Mother’s Day with the Top 7 dedicating tear-inducing songs to the moms and motherly figures in their lives. And in a sign of the times, the contestants also took on viral hits made popular on TikTok.
Along with the usual critiques by judges Katy Perry, 2022 Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inductee Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan, the Idol hopefuls were mentored by Grammy-winning artist and producer will.i.am. Unfortunately, Noah Thompson and Fritz Hager tested positive for COVID. Noah performed from his hotel room while Fritz’s rehearsals aired.
Sadly, two more talents were sent packing with a Top 5 revealed two weeks from the finale. Who will get to be mentored by Carrie Underwood in Vegas? Did Noah and Fritz not being there in person cost them their Idol dream? Let’s unpack.
Leah Marlene
Leah admitted to being a bit obsessed with the Black Eyed Peas when meeting will.i.am. She chose “Electric Love” by BØRNS, which is part of the trend of people kissing another to see how they will react. Will.i.am wanted Leah to embrace what makes her special as she wanted to move around the stage a bit more. Lionel liked how she took willi.am’s tips perfectly when it came to movement. Leah’s mom Deanna was treated to the song “Sanctuary” by Charles Esten, Lennon, and Maisy from the show Nashville. The two would watch the TV drama together. Lionel said she found her artistry. Katy could see a maturity over the last few weeks. Luke liked the purity and quality of her voice.

ABC/Raymond Liu
Jay Copeland
Jay chose “I Have Nothing” by Whitney Houston. The song has been popping up on viral animal videos, and he was fascinated by them. Will.i.am encouraged him to start at a higher key. Katy was impressed with the vocals and runs, calling them unique and artistic. She felt the platinum ticket winner did justice to a Whitney song. Jay’s dedication to mom Christina was “Song for Mama” by Boyz II Men. He felt it embodies a love a mother gives her child. Katy said the growth for him has been phenomenal. Luke felt he is hitting everything perfectly. Lionel could see him stepping into his own. Despite the strong effort, Jay didn’t get enough votes to stay in the competition.
Christian Guardino
Christina selected “Lonely” by Justin Bieber and Benny Blanco because he feels the words. He posted the song on TikTok, but he wasn’t proud of his voice. Now he wants to make it his own. Will.i.am helped him bring the emotion out and build a true connection. Lionel wanted the 22-year-old to realize he wasn’t born broken but unique. The legend finds his talent shines through. Host Ryan Seacrest surprised Michael Buble, who checked in to invite Christian to sing with him on the finale. Christian made some pizza with his mom Karen where the 22-year-old shared he was singing “Dear God” by Smokie Norful for his dedication. A song she listens to as a daily reminder to be grateful. Katy felt it was one of his best and authentically him. Luke liked the soulful performance. Lionel couldn’t believe some of those notes he hit were unbelievable. It wasn’t enough to keep him safe this week.
Fritz Hager
Will.i.am saw a relatability on Fritz’s original “All My Friends,” which he showcased on TikTok. The top-shelf artist was impressed with his songwriting ability. They aired his rehearsal from the night before due to Fritz testing positive for COVID. Luke felt he had the rock star moment using the electric guitar. He said he has all the tools to go a long way. Fritz’s dedication was not only to his mom Sarina but to his late grandma. He wrote a song called “The Ocean” based on the beach house they used to visit. A Mother’s Day gift for two. Luke said he looked and sounded like a pro. Lionel added his star has arrived. Katy said it was one of the most beautiful songs she has ever heard about grandma.
HunterGirl
HunterGirl put her signature country twang on the pop hit “you broke me first” by Tate McRae. Will.i.am felt the platinum ticket holder has the perfect recording voice. However, he wanted her to make sure to convey whatever emotion she is feeling on the stage. Katy called her a natural and is becoming the artist you dream of. Later, HunterGirl took her mom Urla to the beach for some bonding. The Tennesseean chose “Like My Mother Does” by Lauren Alaina to express how much she inspires her. Katy said she still deserves the platinum ticket today with a platinum heart. Luke felt it was a great song choice. Lionel said she did a fabulous job showing love for her mother.

ABC/Raymond Liu
Noah Thompson
Noah went with “Painted Blue” by Sundy Best. It’s a song his friend posted of him performing on TikTok last year where one of the comments said he should perform it on Idol. Will.i.am worked to get Noah to connect with the lyrics on a deeper level. He sensed more vulnerability in his voice as a result. Luke thought it was one of his best performances, especially since the small-town boy checked in from his hotel room with COVID. Noah used his Mother’s Day dedication to honor grandma Karen, who raised him. The 20-year-old construction worker sang “Landslide” by Fleetwood Mac to show what she means to him. Luke said the right vibes are coming from that hotel room and that he looks like a star. Lionel can hear believability and gravel in his voice. Katy felt adrenaline just take over, which translated into his best.
Nicolina
The “TikTok Queen” made a TikTok with will.i.am using “I Gotta Feeling” during their mentor session. For her performance, the Canadian teen chose Heart’s “Alone.” Will.i.am loved how she hit those big notes. Lionel used just a few words after watching: “Star in control.” Nicolina selected a Nonna Clara favorite in “Light in the Hallway” by Pentatonix for her Mother’s Day tribute. Lionel found it flawless. Katy called it A++. Luke echoed their sentiments.
American Idol, Sundays, 8/7c, ABC
Conversation25 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
O
Fans were wrong by not giving Jay the votes
5
-
O
I agree, but after blowing everyone away the previous week, he blew it this week by throwing in a bunch of pitchy runs. He thinks he's making the song his own that way, but he's not good at it. IMO he'll still get a career out of doing the show as many previous non-winners have done.
3
-
-
G
I'm glad that Christian is eliminated, he over sings/screams everything. Nor so glad about Jay because he is young enough to learn better styling with his voice and is much more marketable than Nicolina. JMO
18 13
-
P
Did any one else notice how Leah Marlene and Nicolina snubbed Huntergirl at the end of the show? Mean girls don’t deserve to be in the Top 5.
4 1
-
R
I missed that, but who knows what happens backstage, they may have their reasons.
2
-
-
C
Christian and Jay should have stayed and Leah Marlene hunter girl wasn’t my favorite Noah hope goes forward
-
O
Christian is a beautiful person with an amazing story all the way around and sooo talented. He should have stayed!
5 6
-
O
Nope. No one buys that kind of music or pays to see that type of singer in concert. Add to it the complete lack of charisma or star quality and he has nowhere to go from here. Same goes for Nicolina.
4 1
-
O
I buy that kind of music and most definetly would pay to see that guy in concert.
1 1
-
P
Eccentric! Table for one!
-
-
-
-
R
With many of the critical comments concerning Christian Guardino in this forum, I am so happy to see that VERY SUCCESSFUL SINGER Michael Bublé must seem to think that Christian has a good enough voice since he requested to sing a duet with Christian on the finale night! In 2022, an American Idol should NOT be pigeon-holed. Christian sends a message to America and the world that one can pursue the American dream and make it come true in spite of physical differences. Christian has totally transformed into a more confident performer. Let’s not forget that Stevie Wonder did not fit the stereotypical role of an American music idol, but he turned out to be a legend for decades and is still revered! As far as his singing being “yelling,” I imagine that Christian will continue to have many well-known singers and musicians who will welcome the chance to help him improve his God-given talent!! There are many more “Imperfect” people out in the world who are and will be great fans of his. I pray that he will go on to be a huge success and prove all these nay-sayers TOTALLY WRONG❣️🙏🏻🙌🏻🙏🏻❣️
3 5
-
O
Don't be naive, Michael Buble jumped at the chance to sing on a heavily watched TV show.
4 1
-
O
Michael Bublé has had PLENTY of exposure on many popular entertainment shows—he is worth over $80,000. I am not naive whatsoever; I am well aware of major artists coming on shows like this to promote a new album which Michael will probably do. In my opinion, Michael would not sing a duet with someone if he thought the person was not a talented singer! And if he was only concerned with his own career, would he not want to choose someone he thinks has a huge chance of winning American Idol and be linked to him/her? I truly think he wants to pay it forward. As I wrote, Michael could have chosen ANY singer to sing with on the show. Michael Bublé has a great following, not only in his native Canada (where Christian is from) but he also has a great following in the US and around the world. He is consistently booked since coming out of hiatus due to being with his son and his family while his son battled cancer. Michael Bublé is just a sincere, talented artist if you read all about him. I hope Michael and other supporters help Christian achieve more than what you or any naysayers think.
1 3
-
O
$80,000?????????? My car is worth that, so I'm sure that was a typo. It isn't about money, it's about constant exposure. Queen and Bon Jovi jave been on Idol finales in the past; it's a way to get their music exposed to a younger audience.
3
-
R
Yes. I'm sure Lou meant 80 million, but Bon Jovi is worth 5 times that and they did the Idol finale. Also, I think that Michael Buble is a Rat Pack wannabe and that type of music is dying out. I'm sure he wants to stay current. Not saying his motives are entirely self serving, but business is business.
2
-
R
I’m sure she meant $80,000,000.00 lol
1
-
-
-
-
-
G
American idol lost more fans tonight! Not watching anymore!
Christian was robbed!
10 14
-
C
Christian has nothing to offer at the national level. The title American Idol means the whole package, vocals, good looks, universal appeal, and overall sales marketability. Christian meets none of those requirements.
10 5
-
G
You can’t say none, he has an awesome voice. Furthermore, I am sure they told likes like Lizzo. Adele, etc that don’t look marketable the same. Also if that’s the case stop giving some of these kids false hope by letting them make it this far.
1 5
-
G
He does not have an awesome voice, powerful yes, melodic? not so much. He is too forceful in his delivery and seems too intense rather than letting the music be the message.
6
-
-
-
-
G
Christian was robbed!!
3 11
-
P
He was hard to listen to and watch.
11 1
-
P
He should not have even been in the top 24 he yells . People lean two wards his disability . He’s not good . He just screens
7 2
-
-
P
Christian should have been in finals. Fritz should have gone!!! IM DONE WATCHING IDOL!!!! RIP OFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3 14
-
P
Christian screens that’s it.
8
-
