‘Every Year After’s Matt Cornett & Sadie Soverall Guess: Romance or Horror Movie? (VIDEO)

Turns out, Percy Fraser isn’t the only one who’s obsessed with horror!

When Every Year After stars Sadie Soverall and Matt Cornett sat down with Swooon as our June Sizzle Reel stars, we couldn’t help but challenge them to a Percy-approved game: Are these quotes romance or horror? And yes, of course, we threw a High School Musical quote in there!

Dominating the early game, guessing quotes from Titanic, Wuthering Heights, and more, Soverall confessed, “He always wins every game,” before adding, “I can’t speak too soon.”