’90 Day: Hunt for Love’ Season 1 Cast: Where Are They Now?
Now that Season 2 of 90 Day: Hunt for Love is here, we have to look back at all the drama from Season 1. Today, two of the cast members have gotten engaged to people outside of the show, and even more have found new relationships.
90 Day: Hunt for Love Season 1 premiered in May 2025, featuring eight returning stars from throughout the 90 Day Fiancé franchise and many 90 Day Fiancé newbies who made their franchise debut on the show. Seemingly, TLC’s answer to popular summer dating shows like Love Island and Bachelor in Paradise, the first season of what is sure to be a long-running series brought daters to a single resort in Tulum. There, franchise favorites like Colt Johnson, Chantel Everett, and Tim Malcolm sought to find love through games, dates, and more.
During the Tell All, which was filmed in June 2025, multiple couples were still together. However, a lot can change in a year. Scroll to find out where all of the major cast members from 90 Day: Hunt for Love are now as of October 2026.
90 Day: Hunt for Love, Season 2, Mondays at 8/7c, TLC
Tim Malcolm
Tim may have left Tulum single, but he has been living his best life ever since! During the Tell All, Tim asked out 90 Day newbie, Elise Benson, but she has since confirmed that they never went on their date. Since filming ended, Tim has continued making content on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube and has posted a few times with his “work wife”/90 Day Fiancé bestie, Tiffany Franco.
Tim recently appeared on the 90 Day: The Last Resort Season 3 Tell All, where he revealed that he had connected with Paola Mayfield in the past.
Elise Benson
While Elise didn’t end up going out with Tim, the newbie got a second shot at 90 Day love on 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days. During the season, Elise traveled to Australia to meet single dad Joshua Lawson for the first time in person. There, she found out that Josh had a female best friend and worried that he wouldn’t let her into his family life. Ultimately, they did not work out.
Carlo Nowlan
Before Tim asked Elise out, she dated Carlo Nowlan, another 90 Day newbie who hit the beach on Hunt for Love. While Carlo has led a pretty private life since the cameras stopped rolling, it appears that he spent a few months training for an Ironman triathlon in September. Run, Carlo, run!
Chantel Everett
During Hunt for Love, 90 Day Fiancé veteran Chantel made the shocking decision to ask out her longtime friend, Ashley Bowen, instead of anyone on the beach. While Ashley and Chantel’s mom had a massive argument on the Tell All stage, Ashley and Chantel are still going strong! They even started a joint Instagram page called @ChantAshleyDiaries to document their love story.
As of December 2025, Chantel and Ashley are officially engaged. According to the couple, Ashley proposed on December 17, 2025, and Chantel was thrilled to say yes!
Cortney Reardanz
Cortney Reardanz left Tulum with Colt Johnson, a fellow 90 Day star who took a massive spill, leading to both of them spending most of their time in the hospital during the season. Later, Cortney and Colt appeared on 90 Day: The Single Life, where they both moved on to new people after living together.
On May 11, 2026, Cortney revealed that she got engaged to her much older boyfriend Phil. Since then, she’s been living it up in Miami and spending time with Phil’s grandkids.
Colt Johnson
Since his time in Tulum, Colt has healed from his terrifying leg injury, and briefly went back on crutches after a car accident. Now, he’s healed and is officially walking again. While, Colt’s relationship with Cortney didn’t work out, he revealed on The Single Life that he was virtually cheating on Cortney with his new girlfriend from Brazil, Diana, who he later moved in with.
Tiffany Franco
While Tiffany Franco left Tulum with 90 Day newbie Rocky Russo, she revealed during the Tell All that they had split, and she had moved on. At the time, she announced that she was dating a family friend named Ronnie. However, since she has taken down all photos with him, it appears that Tiffany and Ronnie have split, too.
Rocky Russo
Ukelele-playing Rocky Russo was definitely a standout 90 Day newbie during Hunt for Love. As a holistic fitness coach, Rocky has leaned even further into wellness content on social media since the show. He also posts new episodes of his podcast, The Antidote Podcast with Rocky Russo, once or twice a month.
Jeniffer Tarazona
While Jeniffer Tarazona and Cole Anderson were still together at the time of the Tell All, it was clear that tension in their relationship was brewing due to Jeniffer’s past hookup with Rob Warne. Seeing as Jeniffer and Cole no longer follow each other on Instagram, it’s safe to say that they have split.
Cole Anderson
Since his time on Hunt for Love ended, Cole has returned to his job as a commercial airline pilot. During a vacation to Colombia in October, he wrote, “The past few months have been nonstop; probably the busiest I’ve ever been, but it’s made me appreciate the quiet moments even more.”
Rob Warne
In the months after Season 1, Rob posted a ton of videos with his boy band, 90 Day Bad Boys, which he’s a member of alongside 90 Day stars Jamal Menzies and Josh Weinstein. During the Season 8 Tell All of Before the 90 Days, Elise Benson revealed that her costar Emma Perry has hooked up with Rob multiple times.
Now, Jamal is on Hunt for Love with Emma, and the two have already revealed that they have hooked up, too! Could this be another 90 Day love triangle?
Usman Umar
You know we had to save the best for last! While Usman Umar left the show single, he told viewers that he planned on getting married by the end of the year. It appears that he is still looking for love. That being said, he has released multiple songs, including “Habibi” and “Hankali,” under his stage name, Sojaboy.
