‘Love Actually’ Romances: Ranking 8 Pairings From Worst to Best

Hugh Grant as David and Martin McCutcheon as Natalie, Andrew Lincoln as Mark and Keira Knightley as Juliet, and Rodrigo Santoro as Karl and Laura Linney as Sarah in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures via YouTube

We feel it in our fingers / We feel it in our toes / Christmas is around the corner / And so our desire to rewatch Love Actually grows.

The rom-com film — written and directed by the great Richard Curtis — is celebrating its 23rd anniversary just ahead of the holiday season. Since Love Actually’s release in theaters on November 14, 2003, the movie has become a holiday classic, thanks to its cheeky humor, its intersecting tales of yuletide romance, and a stellar cast that includes Colin Firth, Emma Thompson, Alan Rickman, Hugh Grant, Keira Knightley, and more.

But while some of those romantic subplots are sugar plum-sweet, others land like lumps of coal. Here’s how we’d rank Love Actually’s most significant pairings. Do you agree or disagree with our Love Actually ranking? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

Love, Actually, Streaming Now, Peacock and Netflix

Alan Rickman as Harry and Emma Thompson as Karen in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

8. Harry & Karen

Oof, Harry (Rickman) and Karen (Thompson) have some relationship work to do after he buys a gold necklace for his secretary and not his wife. Instead, Karen finds a Joni Mitchell CD under the Christmas tree. (No shade to Joni, of course.) The film’s epilogue makes it seem like these spouses are finding their way back to each other, but their strife is Love Actually’s biggest emotional wallop.

Andrew Lincoln as Mark and Keira Knightley as Juliet, and Rodrigo Santoro as Karl and Laura Linney as Sarah in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

7. Mark & Juliet

Romantic as it might seem that Mark (Andrew Lincoln) staged a “Silent Night”-soundtracked, placard-enabled declaration of love to Juliet, we agree with Knightley’s assessment that the gesture is “slightly stalkerish” and “quite creepy.” Juliet is newly married — to a character played by the comely Chiwetel Ejiofor, no less — and Mark, as he realizes too late, simply missed his chance.

Rodrigo Santoro as Karl and Laura Linney as Sarah in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

6. Karl & Sarah

We get it, Sarah (Laura Linney) — we’d do a secret happy dance in a stairwell if we got an overnight with Karl (Rodrigo Santoro), too. And yes, we also get prioritizing your ill brother over your new date. But giving up on your romance Karl after one false start? Sarah, Sarah, Sarah… how could you?

Martin Freeman as John and Joanna Page as Judy in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

5. John & Judy

It’s cute how chaste this romance is, considering how Judy (Joanna Page) and John (Martin Freeman) meet — they’re both body doubles for adult film stars, though they only mimic intimacy in those day jobs. When he and Judy finally get together, John exclaims, “I might get a shag at last!”

Hugh Grant as David and Martin McCutcheon as Natalie in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

4. David & Natalie

David (Grant), the new dance-happy prime minister, is totally charmed by Natalie (Martine McCutcheon), his new foul-mouthed staff member, so much so that he goes caroling from house to house just to find her. Yes, they’ll have some HR issues to work out, but we’re rooting for them.

Bill Nighy as Billy and Gregor Fisher as Joe in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures via YouTube

3. Billy & Joe

Yeah, the relationship between rock star Billy (Bill Nighy) and manager Joe (Gregor Fisher) might be platonic… and their bro hug is awkward at best. But as Billy realized at Elton John’s holiday party, there’s no one with whom he’d rather spend Christmas with than Joe, the guy who’s been there for him for years. “You turn out to be the f**king love of my life,” Billy tells him.

Lúcia Moniz as Aurélia and Colin Firth as Jamie in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

2. Aurélia & Jamie

“I know I seems an insane person because I hardly knows you but sometimes things are so transparency…” Jamie (Colin Firth) says in broken Portuguese as he proposes to Aurélia (Lúcia Moniz), the housekeeper with whom he’d bonded as he rented a vacation home months earlier. And she learned English during the interim “just in cases”? Swoon.

Thomas Brodie-Sangster as Sam and Olivia Olson as Joanna in 'Love Actually'
Universal Pictures

1. Sam & Joanna

The sweetest storyline of the movie, for our money, is schoolboy Sam (Thomas Brodie-Sangster) and his infatuation with American classmate Joanna (Olivia Olson), the kind of crush for which you’d run through a busy airport for one last conversation and a kiss on the cheek. Hopefully, their budding relationship doesn’t have to be long-distance!