‘Sunrise on the Reaping’: The Movie’s 8 Biggest Changes From Book to Screen

Joseph Zada and Whitney Peak as Haymitch and Lenore Dove in 'Sunrise on the Reaping'
Everett Collection

The sun has officially risen on the Sunrise on the Reaping theatrical release, which can only mean one thing: It’s time to break down the biggest differences between the book and the adaptation. (Warning: Sunrise on the Reaping book and movie spoilers ahead!)

Sunrise on the Reaping introduces viewers to 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy’s (Joseph Zada) life in District 12 and romance with his girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak) before entering the 50th Hunger Games. After trying to break the arena with the help of a few familiar faces from the original film/book series, Haymitch ends up losing everyone, from his closest allies in the Games to his loved ones back home.

While we were surprised to see that adaptation faithfully captured (nearly) every major plot point from the book, one of the biggest aspects of any Hunger Games story felt absent, as squeezing so much into the movie cost the narrative its moments of contemplation, silence, and lasting emotion.

Think about how often we saw Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) or even Coriolanus (Tom Blyth) think through a decision or sit in an emotion. Of course, Zada was fantastic and brought just as much talent to his role as the previous franchise leads, but ultimately, we felt that the final cut of Sunrise on the Reaping, which favored a rapid succession of book scenes, didn’t give Zada or viewers the space to linger in any one feeling before moving on to the next.

While it’s clear that the adaptation’s biggest disconnect from book to screen was this tonal shift, there were quite a few scenes and moments that were changed between the book and the movie. Below, we’re breaking down all the major Sunrise on the Reaping changes and some of our theories as to why they were made.

Snow mentioning Lucy Gray by name

In the movie, right before President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) introduces Haymitch to Lou Lou (Iona Bell), he tells Haymitch all about his long-lost love, District 12’s only victor, Lucy Gray (Rachel Zegler). While Snow does guess that Lenore is a Covey name and warns Haymitch that “romantically speaking” he dodged a bullet by entering the Games, Snow never names Lucy Gray during their conversation.

Ralph Fiennes as Snow in 'Sunrise on the Reaping'

Lionsgate / Everett Collection

Later in the book, Haymitch watches a tape from Lucy Gray’s Games, which does not occur in the movie. It makes sense why these two scenes would be combined. However, it did feel a little out of character for Snow to directly talk about the woman he attempted to erase from history, even if he is sure Haymitch will die. He’s an elusive guy! Honestly, this felt a bit like a midlife crisis moment for Movie Snow.

Drusilla & Magno’s messy marriage

Glenn Close and Billy Porter were absolutely everything as Drusilla Sickle and Magno Stift in the film, but one thing moviegoers may not know is that in the book, Drusilla reveals their bad blood is incredibly personal, because they’re actually married.

Billy Porter and Glenn Close as Magno and Drusilla in 'Sunrise on the Reaping'

Lionsgate / Everett Collection

Plutarch’s copy of The Raven

Twice in the movie, Plutarch (Jesse Plemons) hands Haymitch a physical copy of The Raven, favoring a blunt representation of Lenore Dove’s namesake, rather than the oral storytelling or music of the Covey as we saw in the book and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes movie. At the end of the film, Plutarch uses the book to remind Haymitch why he has to go on his Victor’s Tour and hold out hope that another tribute can continue the rebellion in the future. In the novel, it’s Effie (Elle Fanning) and Plutarch who greet him and fill him in on how the Capitol falsely relayed the news of his family and Lenore Dove’s passing after he returned from the Games.

Lenore Dove’s graffiti

Another moment that appears to have been cut from the film is Lenore Dove’s District 12 graffiti. In the book, it’s Maysilee (McKenna Grace) who clues Haymitch in that Lenore Dove has been painting her poster all around their district. When Maysilee mentions that Lenore has a secret, and he should ask her about the orange paint under her fingernails, she hints that Lenore is behind the rebel graffiti in 12, which is likely why she got arrested. Lenore’s graffiti was a part of the set design, as seen below, but she’s never connected to the messages on screen.

Haymitch & Maysilee’s bond

Unfortunately, it wasn’t just Haymitch and Maysilee’s Lenore Dove chat that got lost in translation. Most of their bonding scenes, from Maysilee’s Lucy Gray-esque singing to the mutts to her snort laugh, were left on the cutting room floor, including Haymitch’s conclusion that she was the closest thing he had to a sister, because “a sister is someone you fight with and fight for. Tooth and nail.”

Joseph Zada and Mckenna Grace as Haymitch and Maysilee in 'Sunrise on the Reaping'

Lionsgate / Everett Collection

Ampert’s gruesome death

One thing that we’re a little happy we didn’t have to see was the aftermath of all the incredibly gruesome deaths as they were described in the books, especially poor Ampert’s (Percy Daggs IV) squirrel-eviscerated body. Compared to the other books, this was the most bloody and devastating of them all. However, the movie spared viewers from most of the bloodshed.

Haymitch & Wellie’s alliance

One tribute whose death was so horrifying that there’s no way it could have been shown in a PG-13 movie was Wellie (Rada Rae), who is decapitated by Silka (Laura Marcus) in the book. While we understand why Haymitch and Wellie’s short-lived alliance needed to be cut (the movie can’t be that long!), Haymitch finding Wellie incredibly weak after losing Maysilee, and trying to carry her to the end so she could be the victor, made her death all the more emotional.

Snow’s mind games (& Haymitch’s milk)

Our final key difference is how Snow handled Haymitch’s rebellion. While he still killed both Haymitch’s family and Lenore Dove, in the book, Snow anticipated that Haymitch would try to follow them into the Old Therebefore and gave him a taste of his own poison-proof regimen, in the form of milk. Don’t worry, Movie Snow still loved his milk just as much as that one guy in every dining hall, but he didn’t give Haymitch a taste of his own medicine, just in case he wanted to try some of Lenore’s lethal gum drops for himself.

Peeta’s wig

Is it just us, or was Peeta (Josh Hutcherson) not wearing a deeply unsettling wig in the book’s epilogue?

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, In Theaters